What must become

more @gardenstudiogram | click photos to enlarge

.

What a lark! What a plunge! For so it had always seemed to her when, with a little squeak of the hinges, which she could hear now, she had burst open the French windows and plunged at Bourton into the open air. How fresh, how calm …

Virginia Woolf – Mrs Dalloway

There are moments – rare, but unmistakable – when language seems to recover its full dignity. Not merely as a tool for communication, but as something closer to nourishment: shaping thought, steadying feeling, and enlarging the space in which we meet one another.

For some observers, yesterday’s address by King Charles III to the United States Congress seemed to be one such moment. Much has been said about its tone – measured, gracious, unhurried – and about the surprising hunger it revealed. Not for information (we are saturated with that), but for eloquence: language that carries weight without strain, and music without ornament.

.

.

Why should this matter so much? Perhaps because eloquence answers a human need we do not often name. We speak easily of our need for food, for shelter, for company. But there is also a quieter appetite: for words that do not merely function, but form us – words that help us inhabit reality more fully, rather than skimming across its surface.

Poetry has always understood this. And if we listen carefully, we can hear in three great American poets, and in the keenly attuned Irish poet, Louis MacNeice, a kind of compass for that deeper linguistic life.

You do not have to be good …

Mary Oliver – Wild Geese

Please see The family of things

Mary Oliver offers an acceptance of what is. Her language opens outward, reassuring without diminishing. She does not argue the world into meaning; she receives it, and in doing so teaches us how to stand still long enough for reality to disclose itself.

My father could hear a little animal step, or a moth in the dark against the screen …

William Stafford – Listening

Please see Lingering at the well

William Stafford gives us an attention to what is barely heard. His cadences are patient, almost tentative, as though meaning might withdraw if approached too quickly. In his work, listening becomes an ethical act – a way of honouring what lies just beyond the threshold of our usual awareness.

Now I become myself …

May Sarton – Now I become myself

Please see Metamorphosis and Now I become myself

May Sarton embodies an arrival into self. Her voice is more declarative, yet never strident. It unfolds. In her lines, one senses the slow alignment of inner and outer worlds, achieved not through assertion, but through a kind of disciplined honesty.

… each of us has known mutations in the mind

When the world jumped and what had been a plan
Dissolved and rivers gushed from what had seemed a pool.

For every static world that you or I impose
Upon the real one must crack at times and new
Patterns from new disorders open like a rose
And old assumptions yield to new sensation;
The Stranger in the wings is waiting for his cue,
The fuse is always laid to some annunciation.

Louis MacNeice – Mutations

Please see Variables and Inner Universe

Louis MacNeice reminds us of the rupture into what must become. His language carries pressure within it – the sense that any settled pattern is provisional. And yet, from that instability, new forms emerge. His is the eloquence of transformation, where cadence itself seems to register the moment when ‘the world jumped.’

What unites these voices, including the King’s, is not style, but attention to cadence – to the way meaning lives in movement, in breath, in the subtle placing of stress and pause. Their lines do not merely say something; they enact it. The King’s holding the weight of history, unique experience and diplomacy in his person, Oliver’s reassurance, Stafford’s listening, Sarton’s unfolding, MacNeice’s breaking-open – all are carried not just by words, but by the way those words move.

And this returns us to the larger question: why eloquence matters.

In a world increasingly driven by speed and utility, language is often flattened – made efficient, frictionless, forgettable. But something in us resists this reduction. We recognise, even if only dimly, that to lose the richness of language is to lose a dimension of experience itself.

Eloquence slows us down. It asks us to listen—not only to what is said, but to how it is said. It restores proportion. It allows complexity without confusion, and feeling without excess. In its presence, we are not merely informed; we are oriented.

This may be why moments of genuine rhetorical grace – whether in poetry or in public speech – still resonate so strongly. They remind us of a measure we have not entirely relinquished. They suggest that language, at its best, is not decorative, but constitutive: it helps make us who we are.

And perhaps that is why we respond to it as we do – not with mere approval, but with something closer to relief.

As though, for a moment, the world had been properly addressed.

.

archive – a list of all earlier posts

HOME

Concepts

Hmm. There has been, I think it’s fair to say, a breeze of hot air in the inner courts of Westminster this week – just as in most weeks, and just as in my own conversations with myself! By chance I came across some pondering from way back in Summer 2016 today. I’ll carry the re-reading with me into the coming week …

When we have put it into words
windinmywheels.com – 11 July 2016

Another day of surprises in British politics – and a new Prime Minister (Teresa May) lined up for Wednesday evening. I wish outgoing and incoming leadership every possible success. The burdens of high office are immeasurable – and are incalculably demanding across any and all party boundaries.

As I’ve suggested many times before, it would be the sea of words that would most get to me. Language is the vehicle of depth and of essence – but is too easily trivialised, tripping off tongues that have too many, too quick, demands made of them. Something in me insists on reaching deeper than the mere surface meaning of words – and it’s a reaching inwards that I aspire to, every bit as much as a reaching outwards. Richard Holloway has put a finger on why:

… we are creatures who use language and sometimes only know that we know something when we have put it into words. We are, therefore, destined to struggle with language and concepts, to find the words that approximate to the realities we encounter. We must recognise a fundamental difficulty with this at the outset: language can sometimes suggest the reality of the thing to which it refers, but it can never be the thing to which it refers. This is true when we are talking about one another and human experience; it is trebly true in our attempts to describe spiritual realities. Language is analogical, it describes by likening one thing to another; or it is metaphorical, it operates by using dramatic figures of speech that suggest the reality of the thing described in an image or a sound sequence, such as Tennyson’s

The moan of doves in immemorial elms,
And murmuring of innumerable bees.

Language is revelatory. It can bring us close to the reality described but we always have to remember that it is not itself the reality. It is an interpretation, a way of thinking about something, but never exactly the thing itself; it is flesh made word.

Richard Holloway
The Stranger in the Wings

So be we president, prime minister, prophet or observing person in the street, any and all who write, or place their hope in human manifestos must also “hear” them, deep within, if ever we’re to believe that flesh made word might truly be turned into word made flesh.

Yes: leadership on the one hand and “ordinary” human lives on the other are tough calls! Talk is not the same as action – and shouldn’t always be allowed to trump the wisdom found in deep reflection and silence. And too hasty action can sometimes be worse than none.

There are no easy answers to be found when it comes to the governance of nations, nor even of our own governance of ourselves. All humankind then ought to do everything it can to reach deeper than merely skimming words.

When we have put it into words
windinmywheels.com – 11 July 2016